[ View Thread ] [ Post Response ] [ Return to Index ] [ Read Prev Msg ] [ Read Next Msg ]

BGonline.org Forums

Bot Comparison Final Table UPDATED

Posted By: Michael Depreli
Date: Saturday, 28 January 2012, at 7:55 p.m.

In Response To: Bot Comparison Final Table (Michael Depreli)

Here is an updated table for the original Bot Comparison which now includes XG2 and was done with much stronger rollout settings:

XG2 3-ply Checker XG Roller Cube minimum 1296 trials no maximum until error is less than 0.005.

The process for extracting the data from the rollouts can now be automated for XG, GnuBG and Bgblitz although I don't have the
technical knowledge how to do it so if Frank or anyone from the GnuBG team wants to add their data just email me.

I won't be updating the Snowie data.

Many thanks to the rollateers:


Frank Berger
Xavier Dufaure de Citres
Neil Kazaross
Michael Petch
Miran Tuhtan

BOT COMPARISON UPDATED TABLE
CH CUBE
Version Level CH MD WD WP WT Total Cube Total
2 XGR++ 3.668 0.115 0.223 0.199 0.028 0.564 4.232
2 XGR+ 5.458 0.479 0.261 0.391 0.020 1.151 6.608
2 5-Ply 7.082 0.968 0.392 0.618 0.104 2.082 9.163
2 4-Ply 9.787 0.356 1.159 0.566 0.160 2.241 12.028
1 XGR+ 9.226 1.696 0.665 1.686 0.030 4.077 13.303
2 XGR 12.843 0.495 0.989 0.401 0.160 2.044 14.887
2 3-Ply 13.199 1.214 1.003 0.704 0.196 3.116 16.316
1 5-Ply 12.853 2.185 0.932 3.151 0.367 6.635 19.488
1 4-Ply 17.917 0.656 1.740 1.046 0.401 3.843 21.760
1 XGR 16.271 2.417 0.915 2.558 0.070 5.960 22.232
2 3-Ply Red 19.689 1.424 1.160 0.704 0.196 3.484 23.173
1 3-Ply 22.202 2.217 1.634 4.400 0.776 9.027 31.228

Here's the original table:

BOT COMPARISON FINAL TABLE 500 GAMES

BOT

PLY

Checker

Missed

Wrong

D/ND

Wrong

Wrong

T/P

Cube

TOTAL

Errors

Double

Double

Errors

Take

Pass

Errors

Errors

eXtreme Gammon

XGR+

13.397

1.088

0.658

1.746

0.970

0.241

1.211

2.957

16.354

eXtreme Gammon

XGR

22.269

1.661

0.783

2.444

2.173

0.264

2.437

4.881

27.150

eXtreme Gammon

5-Ply

17.169

1.507

0.789

2.296

2.859

0.450

3.309

5.605

22.774

GNUBG

4-Ply

21.599

2.663

0.644

3.307

4.061

0.127

4.188

7.495

29.094

eXtreme Gammon

4-Ply

22.967

0.426

1.647

2.073

0.818

0.555

1.373

3.446

26.413

GNUBG

3-Ply

29.313

0.903

10.276

11.179

0.775

5.880

6.655

17.834

47.147

eXtreme Gammon

3-Ply

27.814

1.831

1.528

3.359

3.996

0.520

4.516

7.875

35.689

GNUBG

2-Ply

33.247

2.763

1.670

4.433

4.261

0.476

4.737

9.170

42.417

Snowie 4

3-Ply

37.424

1.922

1.139

3.061

3.651

0.867

4.518

7.579

45.003

BG Blitz

3-Ply

41.286

1.692

17.263

18.955

4.168

2.159

6.327

25.282

66.568

Rollout Parameters Gnubg 2-Ply World Class 1296 trials or 2.33 J.S.D. Minimum 720 trials

Opening rolls and replies rollout data from Stick's Gnubg rollouts at www.bgonline.org>>

Messages In This Thread

 

Post Response

Your Name:
Your E-Mail Address:
Subject:
Message:

If necessary, enter your password below:

Password:

 

 

[ View Thread ] [ Post Response ] [ Return to Index ] [ Read Prev Msg ] [ Read Next Msg ]

BGonline.org Forums is maintained by Stick with WebBBS 5.12.